Wednesday, November 5, 2014

This blog is now closed to comments.



I have moved away from the park and am no longer knowledgeable about the status of the conversion. 

Since, I cannot respond to comments in any meaningful way, I have closed the blog to comments and removed a recent very long comment that seemed to be more of an endorsement of the anti-conversion lawyer than an attempt to share personal information or opinion.

Wishing all of you a much more peaceful 2015!

joyce

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Apology and Last Thoughts

Survey Confusion:  At the HOA meeting tonight, it dawned on me that the crux of all of the dissension for the past several months has circled around one major point of confusion:  what the survey is actually about.  I apologize for not recognizing this sooner and trying to make the purpose of the survey clearer.

Let's, for the moment, put aside how the survey was done and the "he said/she said" and just look at why it is a requirement in the first place.  

At the beginning of a conversion process, the owner has no idea whether or not the residents are interested in the possibility of owning their lots.  The survey is the mechanism for letting residents indicate their interest in the POSSIBILITY of buying and the POSSIBLE rent protections offered by conversion.  If the survey shows that the residents do not like the general offer that proceeds the survey, the owner moves on to a different way of selling the park … or changes the offer. If he feels like there is sufficient interest, he proceeds with a lengthy and expensive process of mapping, appraising and assessing the health of the park. 

The owners believed that the original survey here indicated sufficient interest, so they proceeded to assemble the application and information required to go forward.  Then they hit the snag at the planning commission and you know the rest.

One resident tonight summarized it well … the owners will either decide to do a new survey, go to court or find a different way to sell the park.  Only they know what they will do.  However, consenting to do a survey with an HOA Board that has fought them every step of the way looks like a rocky road to no where. The courts have ruled on issues like this before and generally rule in favor of the park owners.  Who knows whether they will do so again.

The Board wants a new survey with a Yes/No question.  That's fine.  

However, YES does NOT mean you want to buy your lot.  You can't want to buy your lot, you don't know the price … plus it's not for sale.  It can't be for sale until is is mapped, appraised and goes through all the bureaucratic rigamarole.

What YES does mean is that you support the lengthy, highly-regulated process of developing a reasonable lot price, determining the health of the park, making sure that rent protections are in place to protect the people who are not interested in buying their lots.  YES means that you think in the long-run, conversion would be a good option for the park … even if you never buy your lot.

NO, of course means you do not support that process.  NO, also means that … if there are enough of you … that there will be no conversion, no residents buying their lots, no seniors over-80 getting their rent capped, no lower-income residents enjoying a lower rate of increase on their space rent, no resident control of their own individual situations and the overall control of the park.  With conversion, eventually this would have been a resident-owned and resident-controlled park.

As long as this confusion exists, a new survey has little chance of succeeding and I highly doubt that the owners would offer another survey when people still don't understand what YES or NO means in this context.  And, in the general tone of the past few meetings I've attended, I would not expect the HOA Board to take leadership in helping to relieve this confusion.  

Here's what I still don't understand. Tonight a lot of board members and the audience said they wanted to buy their lots and yet by fighting so diligently … and successfully … they may have sunk the chance they said they wanted. 

Negotiation.  Had the application been deemed complete, the owners were ready to listen to the thoughts that came out of the ideas committee … as well as the list that the Residents for a Collaborative Conversion had come up with.  Between all of us, I think we could have created a revised conversion offer that would have made everyone happy.  I don't know what all the committee came up with but I do know that the RCC had developed a plan addressing the two main fear points:  the range of prices and the necessity to sell the lot with units after conversion.  We could have done so much that it almost breaks my heart that we didn't get a chance.

Deeming the application incomplete because of the survey has put the owners between a rock and a hard place and they only have one ally … the rising local real estate market over time.  The longer the conversion is stalled, the more their property is worth.  These same factors are the enemy of all of us residents as it means that we will pay even more for our lots if conversion ever does take place and continue to pay escalating space rents in the meantime … and maybe forever if conversion never happens.

If litigation goes 5 years (and often does), the value of the owners' property could easily be worth 25-30% more than it is today (individual lot prices will go up accordingly); at the same time space rent will be at least 20% higher. With conversion you might have had an option to control your financial destiny; without it you're living in a beautiful park with an escalating space rent, period.

Leaving the park.  There has been talk of people fleeing the park because of the fear of conversion.  The official real estate records do not support that allegation. However, since last Tuesday, 3 residents have told me that they will have to leave the park… I know that is a fact since I am one of them and I listed my home today.  Sign will be up soon.  

Mesa Dunes is a great, well-maintained park and I did not want to leave. I feel like I have failed the park in not clarifying the issues well enough to relieve the fear.  For that I am truly sorry.  What I wanted when I started this blog was to help calm the fear and confusion over the issues and provide a common area space for the facts.

I've enjoyed delving into the intricacies and laws of this complex process and making so many good friends in the park. I wish I had understood the depth of the confusion about the survey sooner ... since 166 people completed it and 99 said "yes," I, like the owners, thought that meant enough residents wanted the benefits that the process of conversion would bring to the park.  I did not expect the backlash that followed.

I think a resident-owned park could have been a good thing; however, life will go on … we will return to normal … walk our dogs … play with our grandchildren … watch the beautiful sunsets. But a lot has been lost in these past few months.  Perhaps the interim between now and when the owners decide what path they will follow will give us time to regain our peace and equilibrium. 

Joyce Wycoff 

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

HOA Wins; Residents Lose

Sometimes the workings of democracy aren't pretty.  Sometimes the good guys lose.  But it's always hard to watch a contest that's fixed going in.  And, that's what it looked like yesterday as the Board of Supervisors devoted almost five hours to listening to the voices of both sides of the conversion survey issue and then made a decision that was pretty much a forgone conclusion.


If you would like to watch yesterday's proceedings, go to:



What was won; What was lost.

The Win:  The Mesa Dunes HOA Board has been fighting conversion since the results of the survey of support were known.  They won by convincing the Planning Commission and the Board of Supervisors that they never actually approved of the survey form.  The fact that the HOA Board showed every sign of approving the survey … including approving of it and asking for an additional week to complete it in a meeting of about 150 residents … didn't seem to matter much.  There was a lot of dancing on the head of a legal pin in an effort to get to the outcome that both the HOA Board and the Board of Supervisors seemed to be trying to get to from the beginning.

Tom Casparian, Gilchrist & Rutter's litigation attorney, laid out the timeline of the early days of the conversion process in a step-by-step, day-by-day way that made a compelling case showing that it was not the form of the survey that the HOA Board objected to … it was the results.  Why they were so determined to use the survey to sink the conversion is a question that will be explored a little later.

The Loss:  Residents who would like to stop their ever-increasing space rents and enjoy the full benefits of owning California coastal real estate probably will not be able to do so anytime in the foreseeable future.

Lower income residents will not have the benefit of lower rates of space rent increases that would have been offered by conversion.

Seniors over-80 have lost a space rent cap that would have allowed them to live out their days in the park with only a 1% per year rent increase (capped at no more than $100 more than their current rent).

The goodwill actions of park owners who were motivated by pride as well as money and have historically not raised rents by the maximum allowed in leases, paid for water as part of space rent and did not charge for capital improvements such as the $100K (approximately) recently spent on redoing the streets in the park.

Bottom line:  Before yesterday's ruling, the park had the opportunity to gradually, over time, convert to a resident-owned park where, instead of ever-escalating space rents, owner-residents would benefit from the rising real estate market.  Think about this … zillow.com predicts a 6.9% market increase for zip code 93420 for the coming year.  If conversion had gone through and a resident paid $175,000 for his or her lot … within one year that lot would be worth $187,075.  California coastal real estate is always a good bet … but let's say that the rate of market increase drops to 5% a year … in 5 years, that lot could be worth $227,000. (We'll look at the other side of that equation below in the "And, What Now?" section.

What Happened? And, What Now?

In spite of the fact that 166 residents cast their vote in the original survey (56% of the park) and 99 of those responses supported the conversion (59% of responses, 1/3 of total park), the Board of Supervisors decided that the survey did not meet the legal requirement of having been done "in agreement" with the HOA and thus deemed the conversion application "incomplete."  Since the conversion cannot proceed until the application is deemed complete, this action effectively shut down the conversion.

Quantity over Quality:  One extremely disappointing action taken by Supervisor Caren Ray early in the meeting was a count of support.  The people supporting the HOA position had yellow tags that said "HOA" while the people supporting the conversion wore a yellow tag that said "No Survey Redo."  Supervisor Ray asked people who wore the yellow "HOA" tag to raise their hands and did a mental count and they asked the people who wore the yellow "No Survey Redo" tags to raise their hands.

That may sound sort of fair and logical … but there was a problem.  The HOA Board, supported by GSMOL had invited residents from other parks to come and pack the room.  It's an old tactic and it worked perfectly.  I didn't do a count but my guess is that there were probably 50 "HOA" tags and 20 "No Survey Redo" tags.  However, it looked like at least half of the HOA tags were worn by non-residents.

What was even more disappointing about this action was that we had asked before the meeting started to have the non-residents identified because it was obvious that the room was packed.  This was a resident issue and packing the room was just another display of the bullying mindset that seems to drive the HOA Board.

A note about the lawyers:  Tom Casparian is Gilchrist & Rutter's litigation attorney. He doesn't look or act like the stereotype of a litigation attorney … more like someone you'd want for your best friend (or lawyer)… smart, funny, kind and extremely organized.  His presentation was factual, detailed and arbitrarily condensed by the Board of Supervisors' decision to give each presenting lawyer only 10 minutes to make their cases, while leaving almost two hours for comments from the public.  This didn't make a whole lot of sense since most of us who constituted the public comment section didn't fully grasp the intricacies of the laws involved.  I would have much rather had our public comment time more strictly limited and given to the two lawyers.  Politically this probably made sense … especially if the Board of Supervisors had already made up their minds and did not need to be reminded of pesky facts.

Will Constantine, who was hired by the HOA Board about the time that they realized the survey results weren't what they wanted, is a tall, attractive man with a compelling presence.  However, he was nervous, bumbling and disorganized in his presentation.  He didn't make a case, he rambled around a lot, messed up some names and dates and, generally, did not impress. I've read his rambling, redundant letters to the lawyers and to the Board of Supervisors and his presentation style is similar to his writing style.

And, What Now?

We don't know what the owners' will decide.  However, there seems to be four main possibilities:

1.  Litigation.  Tom Casparian is a litigation attorney … he presented the owners' side of the case in a way meant to convince the Board of Supervisors … if they could be persuaded … and in a way that set the case up for the possibility of future litigation if need be.
Possible effect on residents.  I wanted to know what happens if this case goes to court and, unfortunately, there is a lot of history to guide future predictions.  Had the conversion been approved, it would still be a good 2-3 years before the actual conversion happened.  With litigation now a strong possibility, you could tack on another 3 years to that easily … some cases have dragged on for 8-10 years. Using the numbers generated above and taking a conservative estimate of 5-6 years, yesterday's decision could cost the average resident who wants to buy their lot $50,000 (instead of lot prices being an average of $175,000, they could start at $225,000 because of the market fluctuation in all the time spent litigating this pin-prick issue of how the survey was done.) 
Interestingly, in all the past litigations between Will Constantine and Gilchrist & Rutter, the winning track record belongs to Gilchrist & Rutter.  The courts listen to facts and case law rather than counting the number of yellow tags in a room.  So this option will most likely waste a lot of taxpayer money … and HOA member money … and, eventually get to the result that should have been reached yesterday:  that the survey was indeed approved by the HOA Board and the form of the survey followed the law.  I hate waste.
2.  New Survey.  The owners could decide to do a new survey and some of the Supervisors seemingly ingenuously asked, "Why not just do a new survey?"  It sounds like an innocent and simple step.  Just send out a new survey, get the new results and mush on.  However, you have to go back to the fact that the HOA Board has to approve the survey.  If you keep in mind that the intent of the HOA Board is to stop this conversion so that they can negotiate a new conversion more like Sunrise Terrace (Jeff McAllister has been saying this for months in many different forms and specifically at the last HOA Meeting), you get a glimpse of how hard it might be to get an agreement for the form and method of a new survey.
Possible effect on residents:  Back in the beginning of the conversion process, just a few days after the first public meetings held by Susy Forbath, Jeff McAllister showed up at my door wanting me to sign a petition.  I thought it strange since the process as described by Susy seemed like a slow winding through the legal processes with a multitude of protections and hoops that the owners had to follow in order to be able to sell lots.  I didn't know why Jeff McAllister seemed so excited about the process although I now have a conclusion which I will discuss later. 
That petition launched a series of door-to-door canvassing, which some residents have described as intimidating and harassing, hostile meetings featuring misinformation and documentable lies.  If a new survey is launched, I cannot imagine that the HOA Board will simply allow the new survey to be taken in a peaceful, hands-off fashion.  It is their right to lobby for their side of the case and I believe they will use that right extensively.  However, if history is indicator, they will also use it as an opportunity to make up whatever lies they need to convince people that the sky is falling.
Unless a survey could be done in a "no-canvassing" zone (for all sides), I think hostility in the park will only go up.
3.  New Owner. The owners could decide to sell the park as a whole to a new park owner.  Hedge funds are getting into this area … especially now that real estate prices are on the rise.  However, hedge funds have one objective:  profit. And, how do park owners raise their profits … maximize income (increase space rents, pass along utilities and capital improvement assessments), minimize expenses (reduce maintenance and capital improvements).
Possible effects on residents: Most of us are on leases.  I was surprised to read in my lease that the owner has the right to assess me for capital improvements.  My guess is that your lease might say the same thing.  However, our present owners have not passed along assessments for capital improvements.  A new owner might not even make the improvements … or would likely pass along the assessments for them. 
My lease calls for a 4% annual rent increase but the owners did not take the full increase this year and apparently haven't for several years.  A new owner most likely would maximize the legal increase rates. In ten years, my $950 space rent will be $1,406 and in twenty years it will be $2,081. Instead of having the opportunity to own an appreciating piece of real estate, I am now stuck with escalating space rent and since my Social Security will not go up as fast as my space rent, the writing on the wall says I need to start thinking about moving.
4.  Same Owners; Different Mindset.  The owners could decide to keep the park and change the way they run it, implementing all the changes made in #3 and just maximizing their own profits.  This would be an excellent strategy on their part.  In a rising real estate market, they would not only make more operating income, they would have a appreciating real estate asset.  The longer they keep it, the more it's worth.
Thank you, Board of Supervisors, for protecting us so well!
Why, HOA Board? … What drove you to lead us here?

Many of us have talked endlessly about this question of the Board's motivation and it's the question that has driven me to write way too many words and spend way too much of my time on this issue.

I understand some of the past issues that have caused many people to dislike park conversions.  There are bad examples of park owners trying to break rent control.  There are conversions that went bad because they were launched in the midst of one of the most significant economic crises in decades … where jobs evaporated, banks failed, credit dried up, the real estate market tanked, the stock market was decimated and confidence plummeted.  I understand being cautious about this change.  

However, to me, that means looking at the facts and discovering what it would take to make all the residents safe.  The park owners handed us a conversion offer that went above and beyond the legal requirements.  As I delved deeper and deeper into the legal and financial aspects of conversion, I found a few things that would make it better and safer and began to talk to Susy Forbath about possibilities.  It quickly became apparent that they were willing to talk about options.

What I also found along the way were conversions that are giving residents exactly what they want … the opportunity to get out of ever-escalating space rents and gain the benefits of market appreciation in their homes. It became clear that conversion can be safe and beneficial.  So, where did the Mesa Dunes conversion go so wrong?

It takes a leader.

Jeff McAllister is a leader.  He is a big, strong guy with passion and energy.  He and his wife Cathy own a lovely home with a garage on a prime, ocean-view lot.  As Board directors began resigning with the increasing hostility of conversion, Jeff got himself appointed to the board and began to be the face of the HOA Board.

From the beginning he has talked about wanting to "stop *this* conversion" which didn't make a lot of sense to me because *this* conversion was the only one being offered to us.  We might be able to negotiate some better terms, but I didn't see the owners saying that if we didn't like this conversion, we could opt for a different one.

It wasn't until the last HOA meeting that I began to get a glimmer of what might be driving him. At that meeting, he stated that he wanted to get a new survey so he could better negotiate with the owners and create a new conversion more like the co-op form of Sunrise Terrace.  Now, Sunrise Terrace is similar to Mesa Dunes in size and amenities and their share prices (the equivalent of lots) are $200,000.  This seemed strange to me because I've been using Sunrise Terrace as the prime basis for estimating what our lot prices would most likely be for months and Jeff has said that they are not a comparable park and has indicated that he will be able to negotiate a much better lot price (mentioning the figure $65,000 in some of his small group meetings).

Why all of a sudden is Sunrise Terrace the model?  It is true that it was a "resident-led" conversion, a term that is repeated frequently as if it is the most important aspect of the conversion, when actually Sunrise Terrace is a more complicated form of co-operative, that does not create separate pieces of real-estate that are treated like regular, single-family homes by bankers.

The light dawns … finally.  One major difference between Sunrise Terrace and the proposed Mesa Dunes conversion is in how lot prices are fixed.  In the Mesa Dunes conversion process, each lot would be assessed individually and priced according to size, location, views, and so on.  In the Sunrise Terrace model, every resident pays the same price regardless of differences in lots.

In the Sunrise Terrace model, ocean view lots are the same price as back-of-the park lots.  What might this mean in Jeff and Cathy's situation?  They have a large lot because of their garage and also have that prime, ocean view.  They could easily have the most expensive lot in the park.  If the average lot price turned out to be $175,000, the McAllisters would pay a higher price … perhaps as much as $225,000. (This all pure speculation, of course.) Could that difference of tens of thousands of dollars really be what drives Jeff?  

I sure hate to think so, but I can't find any other rational reason why he has fought this so hard, why he has been so willing to lie … even spreading lies that can be easily documented and refuted.  (For a brief list of lies, see the post: Stop the Lies … Please! 

I'm sure Jeff is now planning his new conversion with cheap lot prices … cheap lot prices that are all the same, view or no view … and celebrating the win.  I only have one remaining question … has he forgotten that the park owners still own the property?  Well, actually a second remaining question … what makes him think that the owners would ever talk to him about this fairy-tale, "resident-led" conversion?

Saturday, February 1, 2014

Stop the Lies ... Please!

Tuesday, February 4th, the SLO County Board of Supervisors will make a major decision regarding conversion … they will decide whether the original survey of support  was valid or a new one should be done.  This decision will dramatically impact the future of the conversion.

ATTEND THE MEETING: If you want the choices conversion offers, 
the Board of Supervisors needs to hear about YOUR voice. 
Come to the meeting on February 4th at 1:00 pm and speak up 
or at least let them know that you want the option 
and do not believe a new survey would solve any problems (which it won't).

YOUR VOICE COUNTS: Right now, the irrational voices are shouting loudly 
and the Supervisors think they represent everyone in the park.  They don't.

RIDES AVAILABLE: If you want a ride or more information, please call 
Joanne Mancarella to join us for lunch at 11:00 am Tuesday.

EMAIL IF YOU CAN'T ATTEND: If you can't go to the meeting, you can still 
send an email stating your position but it must be received by Monday, Feb 1.
Email me at jwycoff@me.com and I'll send you the format
preferred by the Supervisors.

******* Just as a refresher *******

The Survey: 166 people responded to the original survey and 99 said they supported the process.  And, regardless of what the HOA Board now says, they approved the survey.  A lot of us were in the meeting room when Susy asked if there was a Board quorum present and if the Board approved the format of the survey.  The Board said yes and asked for an extra week so people could respond. No objections were registered.

This is NOT a "forced conversion."  The HOA Board loves to use the words "forced conversion" as if there were a gun at someone's head forcing them to buy their lots.  Purchasing your lot is completely optional!  It gives those who want to buy the option and leaves everyone else in basically the same position they are now … with some lower income folks and over-80 residents actually in a better rent condition.

What happens if a new survey is NOT needed?  This doesn't mean that the conversion is approved … it means the process moves to the next step and we have the opportunity to negotiate better terms. (There are two more things I want to ask for that would make this conversion truly attractive to all. It is far less likely that we will get these additional benefits if the owners are forced to go to court or do a new survey.)

What happens if new survey IS required? We don't know what the owners might decide … they could take the issue to court and spend a ton of money in legal fees … they could delay the conversion for a number of years (at which time real estate prices would undoubtedly be even higher than they are now) … they could decide to sell to a hedge fund that would run the park in a way that would maximize their profits … they might even decide to do the new survey (however, with the flood of misinformation that has been poured into the park by the HOA Board, this is not likely.)

                                           ******* STOP THE BULLIES *******

In any important change, there are differences of opinions.  Discussing those differences leads to better outcomes for everyone.

That is not what has happened here in the park.  The HOA Board has been hijacked by some very loud and self-interested individuals who have proceeded to bully anyone who disagreed with them.  Their record is almost incredible …
  • They have refused to meet in any sort of open forum when invited by Supervisor Caren Ray.
  • They have sabotaged one public meeting through hostile calls to invited experts.
  • They have lied about their ability to get a "fair" price for the lots and claimed they could get a ridiculous price that has no relationship to the actual market or what any expert or professional would say is fair.
  • They have lied about my role in this process, calling me a "plant" of the lawyers and saying that I was being paid or getting my lot for free. (Not true.)
  • They have lied about what Richard Laxton at Murphy Bank said.
  • They have lied about the space rent benefit for seniors over-80 being "age discrimination."
  • They have lied about the impact of conversion on the value of our homes. (Look at Knollwood or any other area park that has converted.) They actually put this lie in print saying that "everyone would lose an average of $100,000 or more on their homes."
  • They have lied on television about people "fleeing the park." (Sales numbers and prices have changed little over the past 3 years and one unit just sold in 3 days for full price.)
  • They have lied about what would happen to rents, waving scary "market rate" rent numbers in the air like a red flag when few … if any … residents would be effected by "market rate," which over half the park is already at.
  • They have attacked and lied about Susy Forbath, Richard Close, the owners,  John Wallace, me, the office staff, the park maintenance people, the bankers, the area real estate professionals and probably others I don't know about.
How many "they lieds" does it take before we realize these people 
are bullies and not worthy of our trust???

There's only one way to stop bullies … stand up to them, join forces in rejecting lies, find out the truth … and speak up to the Board of Supervisors who are being led to believe these same lies … and thinking they represent everyone in the park.

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

What Are the Facts? #3 "They're Giving them Away!"

Decision Tree
Once more the HOA Board is playing fast and loose with numbers and facts.  At last night's meeting, they said that there have been "40 home sales in the past year … more than ever before."  That part is almost true -- there were 25 sales in 2013, however there were 23 in 2012 (I guess that takes it out of the realm of even "almost true."  Do they ever bother to even look at actual reports?)

Fallacy: Residents are "giving their units away."

Where the HOA Board's message really went off base, however, was when they said that the reason there are so many sales is because the conversion has scared the residents so badly that they are "giving their units away." 

I have been following park sales closely to try to determine what effect, if any, conversion is having on sales and sales prices.  I knew what the HOA Board was saying wasn't true as of October, 2013, but I wanted to make sure nothing had changed since then so I asked for a new set of official sales reports*.  I'll update this post as the 2014 sales are available.

Here's an interesting breakdown:

Year          Total Sales          High          Low       Average
2012                  23               200,000     22,500       82,124
2013                  25               142,000     30,000       75,722     
2013 AC*          16               142,000     30,000       82,950                                      

AC* - After Conversion - In other words 16 of the 25 sales made in 2013 were made after 7/1/2013 when buyers were informed of conversion.  Those sales had the low for the year as well as the high but the average sale price was actually somewhat higher than pre-conversion and the difference between 2012 and 2013 was minimal. 

At this point, I don't see that conversion is having much of an impact at all on sales, quantity or price.

Another thing to keep in mind is that, for a sale to take place, there is a seller and a buyer.  I've talked to a lot of the residents who purchased after the conversion was announced and they seem to be quite excited about the possibility of buying their lots, and for some it was a major consideration in making their purchase decision.

* Thanks Connie Winstead who reminds me that the numbers do not reflect "Sale by Owners" but says those are very rare.


Monday, January 13, 2014

Meetings

Last sunset of 2013
HOA Meeting Tuesday, 1/14/2014, 6:30 pm, upper clubhouse.  Maybe we'll hear some of the results of the committee meetings Jeff McAllister was hosting in December. 

Board of Supervisors Meeting, Tuesday, February 4, 9:00 a.m., 1055 Monterey St., Room #D170.  This is a public meeting focused on the conversion survey.

The question I've asked for months is:  what would a new survey accomplish? 

The only answer I can come up with is that it's just a way to stop the conversion.  However, since 166 of us seemed to understand the survey well enough to complete it, I don't understand why our votes are going to be tossed aside. 

Sunday, January 5, 2014

What Are the Facts #2: The Space Rent Limit for Over-80 Residents Is Real! … or Was!

Just another January day at the beach.
I've had a number of residents ask me about the space rent limit for over-80 residents.  They report being told that it's "not real because it's not in writing." Or it's "not real because it's age discrimination so it would never hold up in court."

Balderdash!

#1.  Susy Forbath put this policy in writing in a green sheet she put out to all residents in the tubes on November 19, 2013.  (See below for verbatim wordage.)

#2.  If this is age discrimination, the same goes for McDonalds, the movies and every other business that offers senior discounts. (Some start at 55, some at 62, 65 or some other threshold determined by the business.)

#3.  In order for this not to "stand up in court," someone would have to sue.  What kind of a person would try to take away a benefit such as this from a senior citizen?  It would have to be a resident of this park to have any hopes of claiming "damages."  I don't think so … to at least I sure hope this isn't something that one of our neighbors would do.

Here's the statement that came out from Susy on  Gilchrist & Rutter stationery, November 19, 2013:
If approved by SLO County before January 1, 2014 and no appeal to the County is filed, starting the month after County approval, space rent for any resident homeowner 80 years of age or older at the time at the time of conversion will be increased by no more than 1% per year, not to ever exceed a compounded increase of more than $100 during the length of tenancy.
Officially … since the HOA and their lawyer appealed the conversion and succeeded in convincing the County to deem the application incomplete because of questions about the survey of support … this benefit to seniors is off the table.

However, conversations with Susy Forbath indicate that, if the application is deemed complete by the County, it will be reinstated.

Wednesday, December 25, 2013

Let Us Remember

Remembering
On this day, chosen to celebrate the birth of a child of wisdom, a day that grew big enough to include people of all lands and all faiths into a universal embrace of peace and goodwill, let us remember.

Let us remember the lonely who are far from loved ones; let us remember those who are no longer with us but touched us with their love and spirit; let us remember the sick and injured and those who sacrifice this day of celebration to care for them; let us remember all who left a piece of themselves on a foreign battlefield; let us remember those who have no homes filled with lights and ribbons and bows tied around bright bits of love and joy; let us remember the hungry and hopeless; let us remember all who stand just outside the warmth of all Hallmark moments.

Today I celebrate with a woman who spent last year alone in a wheel chair, wondering if she would walk again, wondering if life was worth the effort, and a man who recently lost his wife and finds this time more bitter than sweet.  Together we will watch the story of a man who lost himself in fantasy and remind ourselves to remember sweet times and be grateful for the beauty of this day and the gift of living it.

Let us take this time to remember ... and re-member our spirits, our bodies, our communities and our world. 

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

What Are the Facts: #1 "18 Inches of Dirt"


Christmas Pumpkins

Last night's HOA meeting was, overall, a gentler meeting than we've experienced in the past. Questions and strong opinions were exchanged and a few new voices were heard.  If we could continue to meet in this manner, we might eventually establish a bedrock of facts that we could all stand on confidently. 

In the meantime though, we still seem to be focused primarily on opinion, fear and speculation. Large, public meetings do not give us enough time to explore thoroughly the facts that these complex questions require. 

I believe we all want the same thing … reliable information that will help us make our own decisions, an understanding of our rights and protections and a sense that we are being treated fairly.  We want to know that none of our neighbors are going to be hurt by the conversion and that we will not lose value in our homes or have our space rents go up beyond the annual increases called for in our leases.

With the hope that we can all begin to separate fact from fallacy, I'm starting a series focused on some of the issues we seem to talk about most and each issue will be a separate post for easy reading.  Please feel free to comment … together we're smarter than any one of us.

FALLACY:  "We're buying 18 inches of dirt."

Words can sometimes lead us astray … this molehill of fact is used to distract us from a mountain of truth.  

Mesa Dunes is a 50-acre mobile home park where almost 40% of the park is devoted to common space, including 2 clubhouses, 2 pools, a BBQ picnic area (with a fabulous view), a playground, green space, walking trails, guest and RV parking space, a laundromat, roads, water system, sewer system and all those "substandard" lights Jeff mentioned last night.
FACT:  Details of the 19.01 acres of common space is spelled out in The Department of Planning and Building New Project Referral document which was posted some time ago on the blog for your review.  Click here to view - page 4.   
FACT:  The "18 inches of dirt" is actually the depth marker of our individual lots … under that 18" lies not only more dirt but also the underground utilities that we all own in common.
Rumor has it that Jeff thinks the price for our "18 inches of dirt" should be in the $60-65K range.  He didn't mention that number last night but did allude to "much lower prices."  Just to be clear, I would gladly vote for him for King if he could pull that price off.  

So far, I have not been able to find even one data point that would let me believe that the reality of lot prices could be anywhere near $60,000.  While fantasy is a wonderful thing, when it comes to financial dealings, I prefer reality.  And, here's the reality I've found:
  • Sunrise Terrace … shares (roughly equivalent to lots) $200,000 … years ago the shares started at  about $30,000 … land, or a share in land, tends to go up in value, especially when it's California Coastal real estate.
  •  Bolsa Chica (on 227) … land values average $150,000.
  •  Rancho Colinga (Morro Bay) … recent corner lot for sale $185,000.
  •   Knollwood (Santa Maria) … lots are in the $120,000 - $140,000 range.
  •   Pismo Beach (across from beach) … $250,000 for share price, again equivalent to a lot.
Let's negotiate the best prices we can get … but expecting the owners to sell lots for 1/3 of their actual market value just doesn't make sense. 

Sunday, December 1, 2013

Affordable Housing

Paddle boarder at Shell Beach
This week's SLO Sunday Tribune features an article "High Housing Prices Lock Many Out of Ownership" stating that a buyer needs an income of at least $100,180 to afford a median priced ($487,500) home in SLO County.  A year ago, 37 percent of homebuyers in the county could afford a median priced home, now only 23 percent can. In spite of that, homes are selling so rapidly that the supply is severely limited.

The article is filled with interesting data, some of which will be listed below.  However, the important information for us here in Mesa Dunes is how this affects our thinking about the value of our homes, both before and after conversion. The primary driver in the change is the supply and demand for housing … right now there is more demand than supply.

South county tends to be more affordable than San Luis Obispo but it's location near the water and temperate climate keep it in the most desirable category.  Right now Oceano has a median price of $356,000 and Grover Beach's median is $382,900.

We've guesstimated that lot prices will fall in the $200,000 range.  With discounts for early purchase, prices could be closer to $175,000.  Add an average price of $100,000 for your coach and the average package price for a home in Mesa Dunes could be in the $275,000 range … or well under the median price range … especially when you consider the location and amenities of our park.  

Of course, if you have a greatly remodeled coach or extensive decking and a view, your home could be worth more, however, it would then compete with higher-end homes and still be attractive.

It's hard to imagine people buying properties in this price range, especially if our home was purchased many years ago.  However, while California real estate went down in 2008 when the building boom created a glut and the economy tanked throwing many people out of jobs and their homes, if I were going to put money on where prices would be ten or fifteen years from now, I wouldn't want to bet against the upward trend.

There are no guarantees in the world of real estate and investments, but this article makes it seem like Mesa Dunes will continue to be affordable housing even after conversion.

Today's Listings in Sunrise Terrace: (where the HOA is $175 per month)

Some people say that Mesa Dunes does not compare to Sunrise Terrace because their amenities are better.  They have lovely amenities and a beautiful club house.  However, if you haven't driven through it, I suggest doing so.  Somehow, it has a sun-baked feel to me and I much prefer Mesa Dunes.  Plus, it is an over-55 park, something I personally do not prefer.

374 Sunrise … $220,900 (with membership), 1440 square feet … probably 1970s unit
378 Sunrise … $174,500, 1440 square feet … probably 1970s unit.  This looks like a great deal.
816 Eaton … $265,000, 1640 square feet … upgraded
820 Innesley … $279,500, 1368 square feet
807 Muirfield … $295,000,  1440 square feet, remodeled and bonus room
350 Sunrise … $319,000, 1570 square feet, remodeled
251 Sunrise … $359,900,  1600 square feet



Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Taking One Question at a Time

The dunes in bloom.
On a pure numbers basis, the "for conversion" group lost last night at the South County Advisory Council meeting as a hand vote showed about 40 against, 8 for and 8 abstaining.  Of course, most of the park wasn't there to register their opinions one way or the other.

The public comments were passionate and, except for some opening remarks stating that "many people will lose their homes," and characterizing the law firm handling the conversion as "anything but honest," and "downright immoral," most of the comments seemed to be heart-felt statements displaying the spectrum of emotions around this issue … from fear and anxiety to anticipation about the conversion options. 

When it was all said and done the Council reiterated that the owners have the right to sell their property and voted to recommend approval to the Board of Supervisors … with three recommendations (detailed below). Unfortunately those recommendations don't follow state code which carefully prescribes the step-by-step process of conversion.

Metaphors are very powerful and one we've heard a lot was repeated last night: "I wouldn't buy a car if I didn't know the price."  It's a bad metaphor … for one thing a car is actually for sale, our lots aren't.  Right now, we're just going through a process that will turn them into legal real estate that can be purchased a couple of years from now.  The law, and simple fair dealings, require that we be fully informed about the process as soon as it officially begins so that we will have the time required to make our own decisions.

A better metaphor would be building a new house.  Imagine walking into an architect's office and saying, "I might want to build a house.  How much will it cost?"  A whole lot of questions would have to be answered first … how big? what style? when? where? and so on.

Conversion is like that … there are a whole lot of questions that have to be answered before the lots are legally mapped and appraised, the infrastructure evaluated and required reserves calculated, and budgets are drafted to establish homeowners' fees. It's going to take time and a lot of work to answer these questions.  

At this stage of the process, however, the County is tasked with answering two questions in order to deem the conversion application complete:

     Is this a real conversion rather than an attempt to break rent control?  In other words do at least some of the residents actually want to buy their lots? Mesa Dunes only has 36 rent-controlled spaces so we know this is not just a rent control ploy. 

     Is the conversion applicant following all the state and county codes, especially with regard to protection of lower income residents? The owners have filed a Tenant Impact Report with the County outlining the protection for all residents and the basics of how the conversion process will follow the steps determined by code.

The Council listened patiently to the presentations by Susy Forbath and John Wallace as well as the comments of lots of residents and then voted to recommend approval of the application with the following recommendations:

1.  That the planning committee develop and implement a new survey.
We already know some residents want to purchase their lots, assuming the lot prices are fair compared to similar properties.  The first survey demonstrated that and park meetings have confirmed it.  The park could do another survey … but what is the County going to do when only half the residents complete a new survey … just like only half of them completed the first one?  

The original survey had a 55% response rate … somewhere between adequate and good for a mail survey according to the University of Texas's Instructional Assessment Resources.

Are we going to just keep doing surveys until "they" are satisfied?

2.  That the infrastructure is evaluated.
This is a mandated aspect of conversion which was outlined in some detail by both Susy Forbath and John Wallace last night.  However, according to state code, this is done after County approval.  This is not a simple, quick look inspection, it is an in-depth evaluation done by professionals to determine the state of the infrastructure and the level of reserves needed. (See timeline below.)

3.  That the lot prices be made available to the residents.
How can lot prices be determined before there are lots to price?  We don't have legal lots right now … we have rental spaces with guideposts for placing mobile homes. Again, according to state law, lot valuation only happens after the following steps have been done:
  • Obtain Application Completeness letter from County (1-6 months);
  • Obtain Hearing date from County (1-3 months);
  • Provide Tenant Impact Report to all resident household (15 days prior to Hearing);
  • Obtain County approval of Tentative Map (1-12 months);
  • Prepare and file Final Map Application with County (2-6 months);
  • Obtain Completeness letter from County (1-4 months);
  • Obtain Hearing date from County (1-3 months);
  • Obtain County approval of Final Map (1-6 months);
  • Obtain park inspections report (2-4 months)
  • Obtain budget for future Homeowners Association and park operations (2-4 months)
  • Prepare formation and governing documents for future Homeowners Association;
  • Prepare purchase, financing; and transfer documents;
  • Obtain lot valuations; 

There are a lot of unknowns in the process of conversion and that uncertainty makes people anxious and fearful.   However, the state and county have spent a lot of time creating codes and processes that rationally and step-by-step answer these questions.

In the meantime, we need to remember that no one has to buy their lots and 263 out of 299 residents have the option of staying on their leases with its current terms and conditions … basically “no impact.”  

And, if you happen to be one of 36 residents not on a lease, talk to Joanne Mancarella about getting one before conversion happens.  You could be pleasantly surprised at how much protection you have available to you.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Important Meeting: Monday, Nov. 25

The first opportunity to present your opinions about conversion will happen at the South County Advisory Council meeting ... Monday, November 25th, 6:30 pm, 148 South Wilson St., Nipomo.

Comments are limited to 3 minutes.  If you would like more information about this meeting or need a ride, please contact me at 870-656-4141 or jwycoff@me.com.

Living Room Meeting with John Wallace

Missy wonders why she
didn't get pie and ice cream.
Last night was a pie and ice cream gathering with John Wallace, the engineer who is working on developing a parcel map for the park as part of the conversion process and was also involved with developing the new, 118 lot section of the park.  For most of us, it was an eye-opening meeting.  

John gave us a project history statement (included at the bottom of this post) that detailed his extensive work with this park and understanding of the infrastructure issues here.  There were two major points that struck me during his discussion:
  • There is a maintenance plan for all parts of the infrastructure … some visible to us, some not.  We can see the roads being seal-coated but probably do not notice when the sewer system is being maintained or pumped out.  (Although many of us noticed when the leach field was being re-worked due to rodent damage.)  There was an allusion recently at an HOA meeting about "sewer system stink." One of the meeting residents who lives close to the sewer system plant said that they've only noticed the smell a few times when the system was being pumped out.
  • Many aspects of the development of the new part of park came at the request of residents through the HOA Board.  We asked John how hard it was to get owner approval for those things -- such as the new clubhouse and pool, walking trails, renovation of the existing clubhouse, playground area.  Allegations by the current HOA Board have been that they've had to fight the owner for everything.  John says he was told to do "whatever it takes to make it work and make it work well."  
         John's word for the Mesa Dunes owners was "compassionate." 

LOTS.  One thing I didn't fully understand was that, right now, we don't have "legal" lots, although many of us have markers showing the "boundaries" of our lots.  What we learned last night was that those markers were set to show the "rental lot space" and to guide placement of our coaches.  "In most cases," John stated, "those markers will be the same as the legal boundaries, but there will be cases where boundary issues will need to be worked out." 

Several people in the group brought up issues that showed the complexity of determining the legal boundaries between neighbors and settling the individual-versus-common-area issues.  I've just begun to appreciate why this process of conversion is so lengthy and methodical.  Not only does it have to adhere to state and county rules and regulations, it is creating 304 legal entities out of one 50-acre parcel, including a detailed inspection of all of the infrastructure: water, sewer, roads, common buildings, walls, pools, trails …. and so on.  

Mesa Dunes is like a small village … as a matter of fact it's far bigger than the barely-map-dot town I grew up in.

EMERGENCY ACCESS.  Most mornings, I walk Missy down the street and turn left onto a dirt trail that leads me into the neighborhood by the middle school.  This was a critical find for me because it offered us unlimited walking options.  However, I didn't realize it was actually an  "Emergency Pedestrian Easement" until we saw it on an aerial view map and "Vesting Tentative Tract" map that John provided us.  

Not only does this trail give us a way out of the park in case of an emergency, but it gives the kids in our park access to the middle school and walking diversity for others of us.  My neighbors are runners and can often be seen pushing a double stroller with their daughters (2 and a few months old) through the Rocking Horse neighborhood.

One of our detail-minded residents asked why there was only one one road leading into and out of the park … something that had never crossed my mind and another reason why all of us thinking together is such a plus.  The answer demonstrated once again how much thought has to go into a development such as this.  

If you look at a map of the park, you can see two major roads heading into the roundabout … Mesa Grande Drive and Taos/Durango.  The roundabout was designed to be wide enough to handle two streams of traffic exiting the park, thus offering a faster exit in case of emergency.  

PRICES.  Anyway you cut it, most of us wish we knew the price of our lots.  The more I understand this process, however, the more it makes sense that we won't know them for quite awhile.  

I continue to hear people call for having the appraisal done now.  But, how could an appraiser do an evaluation when the lots aren't even officially mapped?  Appraisers … like engineers … don't engage is guess work.  I met with a local appraiser and tried seventeen different ways to get him to give me an idea of what he thought the lots would sell for.  He told me in seventeen different ways all the reasons why that was impossible.  I tried.

Even the timing on this process makes it meaningless to try to put a price on the lots today. It could be two years before the lots are for sale.  A world of things could happen in those two years.

Project History (from John Wallace)

The project (Mesa Dunes) was built in two phases.  Phase 1 was developed earlier by the Hawkins Family and included a 186-unit mobile home park, clubhouse facility and on-site water and waste water treatment/disposal system.

In the late 1980s and early 1990s, Wallace Group assisted the new owners with the development of Phase 2 of the development.  The new phase consisted of 118 additional units processed through the County with the Planning Commission/Board of Supervisors approval of a Development Plan.  Phase 2 included the addition of 118 new residential mobile home lots and many Park infrastructure improvements including:
  • an expanded community water storage and treatment system
  • new waste water treatment and disposal system
  • renovation and improvement of an existing play area
  • a new clubhouse and pool
  • existing clubhouse renovation
  • perimeter fitness trail
  • riparian/wetland enhancement and drainage improvements
  • pedestrian emergency/school access
  • an upgraded entrance with a roundabout for vehicles including school buses (although that didn't work out because of school bus regulations)
  • improvements to Hwy 1 to improve entrance to the park (the road was lowered 2 1/2 feet!)

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

What Richard Laxton Did NOT Say


86 Degrees, 34,000 Monarchs
Paradise.
Wikipedia:  The Big Lie is a propaganda technique. 

It happened last night at the HOA meeting.  And, for a moment, I found my self doubting … wondering could this possibly be true?  After all, where there's smoke, there's fire … and, surely, someone wouldn't say something so outrageous if it weren't true.  Or would they?

Last night Cathy McAllister stood up and made the absolutely most outrageous … and, as it turned out,  categorically untrue … statement and said it came from Richard Laxton of Murphy Bank. I listened as she spoke with conviction and anger.  I watched as she shouted down Judy Hall's innocent question.  And, I took careful notes because, if what she was saying was at all true, I was going to have to rethink a whole lot of what I've believed and written on this blog.

Here's the story:  Cathy stated that she and Jeff had met with Richard Laxton of Murphy Bank and that he said that we couldn't use Sunrise Terrace to think about lot prices since their amenities are so much better than ours.  She also said he said that his experience with this particular law firm was that it priced lots $100,000 or more higher than they should be priced.

She then used my speculation that lot prices would wind up in the $175,000 - $225,000 range and concluded that the lot prices should be $75,000 - $125,000.  Suddenly she believes something I've said???

Since Richard Laxton was one of the first outside professionals I contacted on this journey and he impressed me with his deep knowledge of conversions, mobile homes and area values, I was shocked that he would make a statement so offensive to the professional reputation of a law firm.  I was also shocked because when I originally asked him what he thought the prices would be, he had responded without hesitation:  $150,000 - $200,000.

So last night I sent him an email which prompted another round of emails and then a rather lengthy phone conversation.  In brief, he denied that he made those statements, called them wild accusations and said I should ask the McAllisters to provide proof.

Here's the documentation of this conversation:

Email 11/12/13, 8:21 pm to Richard Laxton

Richard … I'm sorry to get you involved in this … however, at our HOA meeting tonight, Cathy McAllister said she and Jeff met with you.  Below are some of the things she said you said.  I am very concerned because I have based a good deal of my thinking on what I learned from you and from Michael.  I want to give the residents in the park the very best advice I can find and if I misunderstood you, then I need to go back and set things straight.

Sunrise Terrace -- Cathy said that you said we would be sorely mistaken if we used Sunrise Terrace as a guide to our lot prices because their amenities are so much better than ours.

Over-priced lots -- she also said that from your past experience with this law firm (Gilchrist & Rutter) you expect the lots to be over-priced by $100,000.  I have mentioned in conversation that my guess after looking at other parks and talking to various people is that the lots will be in the $175K - $225K range.  So she started saying, "Wouldn't it be better if our lot prices were $75K - $125K?"

Best Guess -- in our first conversation, when I asked you what range the lots would fall in, you said $150K - $200K.  Is there anything that would make you change that guess?  Is there anything that would make you think the $75K - $125K is a reasonable range.  (Oh how I wish it were!)

joyce

Email 11/13/13, 9:08 am to Joyce Wycoff

Joyce

Almost everyday I deal with loan customers who claim I said this & that. Sometimes I am shocked at what people repeat I said about a situation because they didn’t understand the conversation or heard what they want to hear. In the end I cannot make reccomendations to anyone as to whether one park is better than other because it is still an individual choice as to where to live. Since we service the loans we make we hear all the complaints when people need to sell a home and then can’t get out for one reason or another. In the end the appraisers are going to give their indication as to what the lots should be valued at. I think Michael has made that clear. Then after the park owner has made his decision to price the lots, the marketplace will take over and determine what the real values are. Murphy Bank does not set property values.

Sincerely,

Richard Laxton

Email 11/13/13, 9:57 am to Richard Laxton

Richard ... thanks for your prompt response.

Because Cathy's claim is so significant ... that you stated that this lawyer has overstated lot prices in the past by at least $100,000, could you confirm or deny that specific statement.  The implication in what she said was that it was a deliberate overpricing in an attempt to do something devious and that it was plotted by this particular lawyer.

Because this is affecting your reputation, would you be willing to write an open letter to the residents that could be faxed to the Mesa Dunes office and distributed by them?

joyce

Email 11/13/13, 10:04 am to Joyce Wycoff

Joyce

In the first place, attorneys do not set appraisal values! This is exactly why you cannot get involved in hearsay. There is a park on the coast that has been involved in litigation for 5 years on lot prices but those prices were not set by attorneys.

Richard Laxton

Shortly thereafter, Richard called me.  Highlights of that call:

He did not meet with the McAllisters although after a while he did remember a phone call where "some guy was talking about a $250,000 lot."  Richard stated, "Lot prices will not be $250,000.  That is just not going to happen."

He admonished me not to get caught up in this type of hearsay and to insist that they prove such a "wild accusation."  He reiterated that it would be crazy for a park owner to set prices that were too high for the market since they would never sell.  He also reminded me that no one is obligated to buy their lots so why would they if the lots were over-priced.

He agreed that while every park is different, Sunrise Terrace does give us a marker for thinking about lot prices.  He also talked about Pismo Beach Mobile Home Park where the lot prices are $250,000 but they are too high and lenders are not making loans at that price.

Conclusion:  Make of this what you will, but if someone is willing to stretch the truth this far, can they be trusted at all?